Book Report: Sticky Fingers’ Sweets


It’s no secret that we adore sweets around here. So, when Doron Petersan’s book, Sticky Fingers’ Sweets: 100 Super-Secret Vegan Recipes , came out in February 2012, we had to pick up a copy. We even got it autographed by the grand lady herself at the 2012 DC VegFest last fall. But it’s taken us a minute to realllly bake our way through it. After all, we don’t report on books unless we’ve used them a great deal.

The first recipe we tried was the Lemon Coconut Cookies, found on page 127. If you love coconut, they promise to “make you mad in a good way” – and they deliver!

Because these were a birthday gift for a friend, we made 1/2 the batch and still ended up with 36 cookies.  What we’re saying is — the recipe makes a lot!  Generally, we found that Doron’s recipes work very well, but make huge amounts of sweets. If you are a big eater, or have a lot of friends and family to feed, that’s ideal. But if you’re single, or only want a sweet lil’ nibble – go ahead and half her recipes! We found they worked in smaller portions, likely because her measurements are so precise.

We made a few  alterations to the Lemon Coconut Cookies worth noting: First, we didn’t have lemon oil, so we used a drop of lemon extract instead.  Instead of 2 tsp. of lemon zest, we included zest from an entire lemon – the gal we were baking for is a lemon fiend and loved it. Because I ate some of the coconut shreds while we baked the cookies, we had to skip step #8, where you add a coconut garnish to the cookies. Oops. It would have been lovely, I’m sure.  And finally, we noticed these cookies got kind of crispy as they cooled. If you enjoy a harder cookie – like to dip in coffee or to have with hot tea, this is a great candidate. The sweetness of the coconut cookie with the tart of lemon was a winning combination!

Our next adventure with Doron’s book was the Strawberry Rhubarb Pie with Crumb Topping on page 209. We made this recipe to share with clients.  And not only did they love it, they wanted the recipe to make at home!

The pie was bright and delicious, a true taste of spring. But the texture was pretty runny inside when we cut it (we did wait the noted 4 hours before cutting it  which is like torture), and over the next two days, it didn’t set up so the crust got soggy, too. Not sure if this was an error on our end or we had overly-juicy fruit. But when I make it again, I may blind-bake the crust in advance and perhaps add a little tapioca starch to the filling.

The topping was incredible and unique with pistachios. Yummmm! The recipe made a little more topping  than we needed for our pie, so we devoured it with a spoon. Also, don’t forget that catch pan in the oven – when this pie overcooks it is a sticky, gooey mess! This recipe is a little complex. Doron’s instructions are thorough and precise, but I wouldn’t suggest this pie for a complete baking novice.  If you’re new to baking, try the cookies and cakes first! Also – it’s crucial to read her introduction chapter… she discusses her techniques and details you may otherwise overlook – like all her measurements are for sifted flour.

We’ve also made her Apple Pie on page 205 with the double crust. Again, this recipe turns out well – it wasn’t as runny as the Strawberry Rhubarb Pie – but I have no clue if it was the fruit or some other factor.  This was a winner at our July 4th celebration. We used star-shaped cookie cutters on the top crust and instead of lattice, built a star-spangled Apple Pie. Gorgeous!


When you really need to impress the non-vegans in your family, nothing works as well as cake.  In Sticky Fingers’ Sweets: 100 Super-Secret Vegan Recipes, Doron suggests going beyond chocolate for a classy and classic vanilla cake on page 49.  Which is just what we did, and paired it with her Peanut Butter Frosting on page 36. The combination won the acclaim of even our fussiest non-vegan family members! My picky-eater nephew literally ate 1/4 of this cake all by himself. No joke.

We didn’t follow Doron’s instruction on the peanut butter brand for the frosting, as we don’t buy Skippy – we used Smuckers Creamy Natural instead, which has no trans-fats. Our icing was still plenty fluffy, though I’m sure with her fave brand it would have been even lighter and dreamier.  Seriously though, no one noticed. The cake was soft, velvety and moist. The frosting was thick and rich and smooth.  Another home-run!

From dessert to breakfast. Our next recipe  was the Pecan Spice Coffee Cake on page 172.  And what about this recipe? Doron promises you will jump out of bed without an alarm when you know this is waiting for you. Yes – it’s that good!

I mean, holy crumb topping, Batman! Who doesn’t love a tender coffee cake with a nutty pecan topping?  We did make a few alterations to this recipe. First, we toasted the pecans a little in a cast iron pan before adding them to the topping recipe. This gave them a little more depth and flavor. Next, before juicing the lemon the recipe calls for, we also zested it and threw the zest into the cake. Cuz why waste all that lemony heaven? I’m not sure what Doron would say, but we loved the zing it gave this coffee cake. I mean, truthfully, we can use a little zing in the morning to get us going. But the coffee cake was among the easier of the recipes we tried and it was moist and satisfying. A great way to begin your day!

Our only total bomb in Sticky Fingers’ Sweets: 100 Super-Secret Vegan Recipes was the Green Tea Pound Cake on page 266. This recipe is in the chapter from the Seoul-location of Sticky Finger’s Bakery. I’m a green tea maniac – it’s not unusual for me to drink about 8 to 10 cups of green tea on any given day, so I was ecstatic to try this recipe.  Doron promises the flavor is like a green tea latte. To which we thought… well, sort of.


The Green Tea Pound Cake was really dry and crumbly. It was not as smooth or silky as her other recipes, and definitely didn’t have the usual heft or creaminess of a pound cake. We had to “reassemble” several pieces for the picture. All of that said – I would totally try to make it again. I think it needs something more to give it a true pound cake mouthfeel and you know, I’m just the kind of gal who’s willing to try again for a Green Tea Pound Cake! When we get this recipe figured out, I’ll update the post and let you know what we try. 🙂

One so-so cake didn’t slow us down, though. We moved right on to page 135 and tried the Sweet-and-Salty Cookies.  These were wonderfully surprising and sophisticated. I know, you’re thinking “How can an oatmeal cookie be sophisticated?” but somehow, it reaches that magical target of both satisfying and upscale.


I think it’s the salt and chocolate combo. We used black Hawaiian salt. Scrumptious.  Serve this to your foodie friends or take the cookies uptown to impress the types who have personal chefs.  We shared them at a friends’ dinner party. Several people asked for the recipe and there were no leftovers to take home. It was only disappointing because I wanted leftovers to dip in my almond milk for breakfast the next day.

Isn’t there something to be said for saving the best for last? That’s what we did. The Sticky Fingers’ Sweets: 100 Super-Secret Vegan Recipes cheesecake recipe on page 217 was hands-down the BESTEST selection we have tried so far in the book. Actually, we’ve made this quite a few times.  Sometimes we share it. Sometimes, we do NOT share it…


Doron writes that if you learn to make this delectable vegan cheesecake, “you will want for nothing.” And when you take the first bite, you will know just how truthful she is being! The cracker crust is perfect – lightly sweet and rich. The cheesecake itself – creamy, smooth, decadent, indulgent. Ohhh goodness… I am starting to drool a little just thinking of this dessert.

A few things – you should *probably* share this. It’s heavy-duty and in this instance vegan and health-food are not the same thing. We followed Doron’s suggestion and used Tofutti Better than Cream Cheese and Tofutti Sour Supreme in this recipe, but there are lots of other brands out there now. We can’t say how they work, but the Tofutti is smooth and blends well to a true cheesecake texture. As we made this recipe several times, we slowly modified a few things: We like it better with 3 Tablespoons of Ener-G Egg Replacer; we add two teaspoons of vanilla; another addition is the juice of one orange and two lemons as well as the zest from one whole lemon and one whole orange.  Adding all the vanilla and citrus makes the cheesecake not just sweet and creamy, but also fruity and bright. Sigh… how I wish I had this slice of cheesecake on the desk right now…

Overall, Doron’s Sticky Fingers’ Sweets: 100 Super-Secret Vegan Recipes is a rock-solid vegan dessert cookbook. Some recipes are complex or require upscale kitchen equipment like a food processor or stand mixer, so it’s not as ideal for beginning bakers. she also prefers dry ingredients to be measured by weight – which is only possible if you have a kitchen scale. She gives cup measures, too, but in her preface, explains that baking is a science and scales are more precise.  The chapter “Basics” goes into depth about the equipment and techniques the book utilizes, and it’s important to read this part before you get into baking! If you have the ability to follow directions and pay attention to what you are baking, this book will be very, very good to you. If you need easy recipes and tend to wander out of the kitchen while you work, these recipes might be too much for your current culinary level.

We have much more to explore in this wonderful book – on page 52 is a vegan Tiramisu recipe; a Champagne Cake with Passionfruit Frosting is on page 80. Are you a fan of the Bakery? You’ll find Doron’s recipes for Cowvin Cookies, Little Devils and Sticky Buns in Chapter 4. Keep going and on page 193 you’ll see Strawberry Lemonade Whoopie Pies and Chocolate Creme pie on page 248.

You can get your own copy of Sticky Fingers’ Sweets: 100 Super-Secret Vegan Recipes online at Amazon or stop by the Bakery in person, 1370 Park Rd NW  Washington, DC 20010. It costs $27.50 and is worth every cent – after all, you can’t even pick up a dozen vegan cupcakes at Whole Foods for $27!

Thanks Doron, for writing your first cookbook and sharing your super-secret treats with all of us! We look forward to the next book – perhaps revealing the recipes for Sticky Finger’s wonderful biscuits and gravy, no-egg breakfast muffins, cilantro slaw and veggie chili! Mmm…. here’s to dreamin!

One response »

  1. Pingback: Stomping Ground: Stickyfingers | the dirty hippie & the bohemian girl

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s